Collecting undervalued coins is akin to going on a treasure hunt—discovering hidden gems that others may overlook. While some coins might not appear extraordinary at first glance, their unique stories, low mintage, or historical significance can make them highly valuable over time. Below are nine coins that are often underappreciated but have the potential to appreciate in value.
1943 Steel Wheat Penny
Why It’s Special: In the midst of World War II, copper was in short supply, so the U.S. Mint struck pennies using zinc-coated steel. While these coins are common in circulated condition, uncirculated examples are far rarer and carry significant value.
Current Value:
- Circulated: $10–$50
- Uncirculated: Up to $1,000
Why It’s Worth Considering: The historical connection to WWII and the scarcity of higher-grade examples make this coin appealing to collectors.
1964 Kennedy Half Dollar (90% Silver)
Why It’s Special: The 1964 Kennedy Half Dollar was the last regular issue coin made with 90% silver. This coin became a symbol of the country’s mourning after President Kennedy’s assassination.
Current Value:
- Circulated: $10–$20
- Uncirculated: $50–$100
Why It’s Worth Considering: With silver prices on the rise and its emotional significance, this coin is positioned for potential appreciation.
1970-S Small Date Lincoln Cent (Proof)
Why It’s Special: This coin features the “small date” variety and was minted in limited quantities, making it a rare find in proof condition.
Current Value:
- PR69 or Higher: $30–$100
Why It’s Worth Considering: Its rarity and growing recognition among collectors suggest it could become an even more valuable asset over time.
2009 Lincoln Bicentennial Cent Series
Why It’s Special: Created to commemorate Abraham Lincoln’s 200th birthday, the series features four different reverse designs depicting significant moments in Lincoln’s life.
Current Value:
- Circulated: $1–$5
- Uncirculated: $10–$50
Why It’s Worth Considering: These coins have both historical and numismatic appeal, and their limited mintage makes them desirable for collectors and history enthusiasts alike.
1942-P Jefferson Nickel (35% Silver, War Nickel)
Why It’s Special: Due to wartime shortages, the 1942-P Jefferson Nickel was the first to be minted with 35% silver, making it a unique piece of U.S. coinage from the World War II era.
Current Value:
- Circulated: $1–$3
- Uncirculated: $10–$50
Why It’s Worth Considering: The coin’s silver content and historical ties to the war effort make it a standout piece in any collection.
1976 Bicentennial Eisenhower Dollar (40% Silver)
Why It’s Special: Produced to celebrate the United States’ 200th anniversary, this large coin features the distinctive Eisenhower design. Many collectors overlook the silver-proof and uncirculated versions, which are especially valuable.
Current Value:
- Uncirculated: $15–$25
- Proof: $30–$50
Why It’s Worth Considering: The combination of historical significance and silver content makes this a great, affordable option with potential for future growth.
1955 Franklin Half Dollar
Why It’s Special: With a mintage of just over 2.4 million, the 1955 Franklin Half Dollar is often overshadowed by its successor, the Kennedy Half Dollar.
Current Value:
- Circulated: $15–$50
- Uncirculated: $100–$300
Why It’s Worth Considering: Its limited mintage and growing interest from collectors make it a coin with great investment potential.
1916-D Mercury Dime (Good Condition)
Why It’s Special: The 1916-D Mercury Dime is one of the rarest coins in the series, with a mintage of only 264,000, making even lower-grade examples highly sought after.
Current Value:
- Good Condition: $800–$1,200
- Higher Grades: Much higher
Why It’s Worth Considering: Its rarity and strong collector demand make this coin one of the most valuable finds for any serious numismatist.
2000-P Sacagawea Dollar (Cheerios Dollar)
Why It’s Special: The 2000-P Sacagawea Dollar is famous for being part of a Cheerios promotion, featuring a unique design detail on the reverse side of the eagle.
Current Value:
- Depending on Condition: $1,000–$5,000
Why It’s Worth Considering: The coin’s limited availability and its connection to a unique marketing campaign make it highly coveted by collectors, and its rarity could lead to significant value growth.
These coins, while often overlooked in favor of more famous counterparts, offer collectors the chance to invest in items with low mintage, rich historical value, and unique characteristics. By identifying these hidden gems now, collectors can get ahead of the curve before these coins rise in both popularity and worth.
